To respond to the original post, I will share a perspective of someone who was born and grew up in India but has then spent more than that much time outside of India.
Growing up in lower middle class in India, that's all I knew. And, it was always a supporting environment - and I fell in love as much as I grew into it

Having said that, this love is hardly a static thing - as no love is. But, it is not quite so unconditional any more; I do not defend India without looking at the right and wrong of it anymore - something I might have done earlier.
A lot of people mention religion. I was intellectually starting to disassociate myself from religion before leaving India - and completed that process after I moved away. Being able to be reach my own intellectual decision in late teens (while part of a religious family) speaks to the strength. On the other side, I have grown to have less and less patience with a lot that goes on in the name of increasingly commercialized religion in India.
There is something about core Indian value system, the sense of right and wrong that I learned as a child - from stuff like Kabir das, Premchand, panch tantra, Gita, sufi thought and literature- that I really cherish. To me, some of that is the essence of what Indian culture has to offer and I have come to value that really invaluable gift. It is what it core aspect of Indian culture at its best. The other side I mention here is that I have seen the same culture I value so much being swept away (perhaps for good) in the more recent years. I hope tomorrows India will be more resilient enough to rediscover that, but not confident.
And, I just love the people. I find the ordinary, often poor, working people struggling to make a living and yet combining a lot of wisdom in them, if anyone cared to engage with them. I guess I am inclined to be sympathetic to this class world over, but I identify with them as the 'people' I come from. I am less enamored with the politicians who appeal to the religious difference to get elected, and polarization they have produced. [I guess it isn't unique about India, but this is a land where coexistence was practiced for long. Perhaps that is just my idealized fantasy.]
I love India and Indians for valuing the investment in education. I love the sight of children - rich and poor - headed to school in earnest. The other side I see that the education system is producing a lot of 'educated' but few enlightened.
I love it for my family I associate it with.
Edited by kavindra, 27 September 2009 - 12:12 PM.