Jump to content

Welcome to Gourmet India

Welcome to Gourmet India, like most online communities you must register to view or post in our community, but don't worry this is a simple free process that requires minimal information. Whats more you can use your Facebook or Twitter account to Sign In
  • Start new topics and reply to others, Subscribe to topics and forums to get automatic updates, Add events to our community calendar, Get your own profile and make new friends, Customize your experience here!
  • Enter contests and schemes
Guest Message by DevFuse
 

Chana


  • You cannot reply to this topic
8 replies to this topic

#1 hyderabadi foodie

  • Members
  • 14 posts

Posted 05 March 2010 - 12:56 AM

According to what I came to know, Fresh green chickpeas/Hara Chana/Fresh Green Garbanzos are dried in the sun, and we get Kala Chana/Black Chickpeas. When these dried Kala Chana are skinned and split we get Chana dal/Bengal gram.
But when the dried Kala Chana is roased, and the skinned and split we get Bhuna Chana/Dalia/Roasted Chana dal/putnala pappulu.

I have a doubt, in the above process of the chana, where does Garbanzo beans/White chickpeas come? How do we get them? I mean do some fresh green chickpeas dry into white garbanzos and some into black chickpeas? and when the white chickpeas are skinned and split do we get bengal gram/chana dal just like we get from kala chana?

Please clear my confusion.
Thanks.

Edited by hyderabadi foodie, 05 March 2010 - 01:02 AM.


#2 Gautam

    Advanced Member

  • Advanced Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 1,045 posts
  • Gender:Male

Posted 07 March 2010 - 12:12 AM

Black chana and white/kabuli chana are two separate ecotypes or breeding groups of the same legume Chickpea, Cicer arietinum.

The smaller black chana has a rough or wrinkled seed coat, more of certain compounds and fiber than the smooth coated kabuli/white types. Consequently. the black/desi types take longer to digest, and have a low glycemic index. This is good for those with blood sugar issues. You can taste the astringency, the kashaya, in your mouth versus the smoother mouth feel of the kabuli types!

Indian besan [raw flour] & sattu [roasted/ parched & pounded] is made ONLY from the skinless BLACK DESI CHANA, never from the kabuli white types, as far as I know.

Green chana is derived from the immature pods of the chickpea plant. In India, it was most commonly plants of the black or desi type. It is quite an expensive delicacy, as a huge numberof palnts must be sacrificed and much time taken to shell out an appreciable amount. Each plant bears only a few pods, and the temptationto snack on the green chana is very high. In Bihar, a great many delicacies are made with this fresh green chana. Whether it is also dried, I cannot say. But the regular black chana on sale is not this green chana. Rather, itis the MATURE FORM of the green chana, left to grow on and DRY NATURALLY on the bushy plants. Then they are beaten out by various methods.

An aside: after the green chana are shelled out, it involves uprooting the whole plant. Therefore it is quite wasteful, since the full yield potential has not been realized.Anyway, theshoottips ofthechickpeabush arevery tender and agreeably sour;they make a very delicious green. The rest of the bush is fed to cattle. Mind you, this sort of thing can only be afforded by thevery rich or the extremely poor, the lattter because they have such extremely dry soil that they cannot afford even the one or two irrigation necessary to bring the crop to maturity. In that case, they uproot the cropand sell it in bunches to big cities like Calcutta. Like poorfishermen, I doubt they get to eat any of their own delicacy.

In my childhood the standard sattu used to be 2/3 fresh roasted chana and 1/3 fresh roasted barley flour. Barley is much more drought resitant than wheat. These used to be roasted fresh daily and in winter, huge sweet potatoes in the embers.Boiled chana and roasted sweet potatoes were the diet of many districts in Bihar, and very delicious too, accompanied by tea, with some chapatties made of wheat+milo and some mustard oil & coarse salt.

#3 Gautam

    Advanced Member

  • Advanced Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 1,045 posts
  • Gender:Male

Posted 13 March 2010 - 04:25 PM

@ H.Foodie:

Here is a blog showing beautiful photographs with explanations clarifying all your questions re: black/desi chana and kabuli chana :

Green Chickpeas (Hara Chana / Cholia) | jugalbandi

#4 ravum

    Member

  • Super Administrators
  • PipPip
  • 87 posts
  • Location:Bangalore

Posted 25 March 2010 - 08:29 AM

A knowledgeable post as usual Gautamda, what about the small brown desi chana - is it a variant of black desi chana?

How is sattu served? Have only used it as a stuffing for parathas.

#5 Gautam

    Advanced Member

  • Advanced Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 1,045 posts
  • Gender:Male

Posted 08 April 2010 - 10:37 AM

View Postravum, on 25 March 2010 - 08:29 AM, said:

A knowledgeable post as usual Gautamda, what about the small brown desi chana - is it a variant of black desi chana?

How is sattu served? Have only used it as a stuffing for parathas.

Dear Ravum,

Sorry for the delay. The brown and black are the same breeding group and "market class", differing only in the amount and composition of some of the compounds present in the skin. You ask about sattu and I shall recapitulate my limited knowledge from the Bihar-Bengal interface. India certainly would have many more ways of using this product and I hope others will join in. Sattu here is the ancient Vedic shaktu, the very staff of life for the Aryans who composed the Rksamhita. References abound, too many to cite. BUT we all recognize AASHIRVAAD. What's that? TRAYA - AASHII =the 3 AAShiis, parched barley flour i.e. shaktu, ghee & yoghurt.

So, Ashirvad is the wish that the Three Ashi-s reside with you: the ultimate good eats of the Rgvedis, besides the occasional boiled horse, that was dispatched by strangling by the special class of Samaga priests, the SHAMITA, they who make silent!! Shaktu would be scattered around the PARIDIHI, the sacred perimeter cordoning off the yagashala. All within would receive a yajnabhAga, share of the sacrifice. You can gauge that the priests were muscular guys. It is not easy for one man to garotte the pick of the stallions in the tribe. Also, fires were started by the priests, two holding down the arani block, one manipulating the heavy bow drill that created the friction.

8 balls of barley shaktu mixed with water, each as large as a peacock’s egg [which is NOT large!]: that is the amount of food prescribed for a renunciant. I have known those who have taken that seriously and have gone on to great things. The present leaders of Hindu maths bulging with fat should reflect what their claims to spiritual leadership are, in the light of this injunction.

Tibetans survive on barley sattu, mixed with Tibetan style pu-erh tea. The fortunate have butter tea and mix this in with their sattu. Even more fortunate people add delicious yak butter at various stages of ripeness to the sattu, and wash it down with pho-cha. I love pho-cha! Try it made with the real brick tea.

We have spoken of the standard 1:3 barley:chickpea sattu that used to be popular in my youth, freshly roasted & ground each day. It was intoxicating in aroma and taste and you can see from the ratios, a complete food.

It was mixed with water, and consumed with oil pickles, raw onions, and green chilies. It created a VERY strong thirst & compelled you to seek out water, a very important survival mechanism for the rickshaw pullers and thelawallahs of Kolkata.

Some Bangalis settled in Bihar or the districts bordering Bihar had the innovative & delicious custom of taking that dough, masking it very soft, almost a liquid paste, and eating it with rice, vegetables and even dal, like another side. Very interesting, and not found in inner Bengal.
These Bangalis would love to thickly coat their MURI, murmura or puffed rice, with sattu, after it had been given the customary mustard oil dressing. Eaten with peanuts, chopped green chilies, some black salt, and occasionally bajjis, this also is a novel use of sattu.

Back to the dough: mixed with chopped oil pickle and/or green chili, the crowning glory would be its use as a stuffing for LITTI. A thick wheat flour dough ball stuffed with sattu dough roasted directly over cowdung patties may not sound like much, nor fit Western standards of haughty cuisine, but I would give much to taste once more the LITTI made by skilled hands: the fresh ground flour, the patient kneading, the cowdung created of a diet of leaves, straw and fodder and an entire universe just vanished in the twinkling of an eye. No ghee, no nothing, just littis for dinner.
In a little oil or ghee with cumin temper, you may fry minced onions or not, ginger-green chili or not, then whatever masala you need, then sattu, brown sugar. You make a dry filling to place, as you said, between parathas, or dalpuris. Filling for khasta kachori.

FRESH HOT SATTU in hot milk, as a gruel with bananas, brown sugar, a hint of cardaom. You can even try it in a sort of payasam, using just nutty chickpea sattu.

I wonder if you could sauté garlic, parley, basil, in EVOO, then chickpea sattu and use it to dress angel hair pasta or toss it with orzo? Of course, I am an uncivilized animal, and will enjoy any thing if it has sattu.

I find the concept of leaching bitter melons of bitterness self-defeating. If the nutraceutical property is in the bitter stuff, why throw it away and then cook the melon in a bunch of oil and rich stuff? The whole idea behind eating bitters is to give your liver and bile glands a break from rich food!! Sattu cuts the perception of bitterness. If you stuff bitter melon with a sattu and vegetable stuffing, like green beans, then you can cook the whole melon without extracting that bitterness or frying it. [ I wouldn’t know for certain!! like many Bangalis, I have a very strong liking for bitterness, conditioned from infancy.]

#6 lady_on_recipe_hunt

    Advanced Member

  • Advanced Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 297 posts
  • Gender:Female
  • Location:USA

Posted 06 November 2011 - 10:07 PM

Few days back I had soaked Kala Chana...partly I used for making curry and some I sprouted. I refrigerated sprouted ones and forgot about it. After three weeks sprouted Black chick peas were looking perfectly fresh. Since I was hesitant to consume, I planted them in a big pot. Here they are after three weeks. Some I planted in a ground and as soon as they turned into tiny greens, Rabbit enjoyed nice feast of Kala Chana greens. Now I need to quickly cook those Chana greens before winter gets more cold.

Posted Image

#7 Suresh Hinduja

    Suresh Hinduja

  • Super Administrators
  • PipPipPip
  • 3,772 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Bangalore - INDIA
  • Interests:food innovation
    golf
    single malt

Posted 06 November 2011 - 10:26 PM

Not heard of this usage, are they edible?
I fry by the heat of my pans
http://www.gourmetindia.com

My Photos
Album: My Pixels
315 images
48 comments

#8 Suresh Hinduja

    Suresh Hinduja

  • Super Administrators
  • PipPipPip
  • 3,772 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Bangalore - INDIA
  • Interests:food innovation
    golf
    single malt

Posted 07 November 2011 - 09:11 AM

Sorry, just saw this upthread in Gautamda's post. Do let us know how it turns out.

Quote

An aside: after the green chana are shelled out, it involves uprooting the whole plant. Therefore it is quite wasteful, since the full yield potential has not been realized.Anyway, theshoottips ofthechickpeabush arevery tender and agreeably sour;they make a very delicious green. The rest of the bush is fed to cattle. Mind you, this sort of thing can only be afforded by thevery rich or the extremely poor, the lattter because they have such extremely dry soil that they cannot afford even the one or two irrigation necessary to bring the crop to maturity. In that case, they uproot the cropand sell it in bunches to big cities like Calcutta. Like poorfishermen, I doubt they get to eat any of their own delicacy.

I fry by the heat of my pans
http://www.gourmetindia.com

My Photos
Album: My Pixels
315 images
48 comments

#9 Dr. Raman Kumar

  • Members
  • 6 posts

Posted 22 November 2011 - 03:36 PM

View PostSuresh Hinduja, on 06 November 2011 - 10:26 PM, said:

Not heard of this usage, are they edible?

" Hare chane ke patton ka saag ", yummmy.

Hare chane ki daal ... another yum... My mother used to make it.

Read my posts at http://www.bcmtourin...m/recipes-f82/.

I write as Gulloo, my childhood name.

You might like them

Edited by Dr. Raman Kumar, 22 November 2011 - 03:38 PM.






1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users